← Back to Blog
Compliance
The Janus Decision and What It Means for Union Election Compliance
By Votem Compliance Team·April 9, 2026
## What Is the Janus Decision?
In June 2018, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in *Janus v. American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees* (AFSCME) that public-sector unions cannot require non-members to pay agency fees. The 5-4 decision overturned *Abood v. Detroit Board of Education* (1977), which had allowed such fees for 41 years.
The practical effect: public-sector unions saw immediate membership and revenue declines as some members chose to opt out of dues payment while retaining union representation rights.
## Why Janus Intensifies LMRDA Compliance Pressure
The Janus decision did not change LMRDA Title IV — but it changed the political and financial environment in which unions operate elections.
**Increased member scrutiny.** With members now making active choices about union participation, leadership elections face heightened scrutiny. Members who opt out of dues are still entitled to vote in officer elections under LMRDA. Any election irregularity — real or perceived — becomes a flashpoint.
**DOL complaint volume.** Following Janus, the Department of Labor's Office of Labor-Management Standards (OLMS) saw an uptick in election complaints from dissatisfied members. Unions that cannot produce a complete, auditable election file are vulnerable.
**Challenger campaigns.** Janus emboldened reform caucuses and challenger slates. Contested elections are now more common, and losing candidates are more likely to file OLMS complaints challenging the process.
## LMRDA Title IV: The Compliance Framework That Matters
LMRDA Title IV governs officer elections for private-sector unions. Key requirements include:
- **Secret ballot elections** for all local union officers
- **15-day advance notice** to all members before nominations
- **Reasonable opportunity** for all members in good standing to be candidates
- **Equal campaign rights** for all candidates
- **Preservation of all election records** for one year post-election
- **DOL oversight**: any member may file a complaint within one month of the election
## What a Defensible Election File Looks Like
A DOL-ready election file should include:
1. Voter eligibility list with dues status at the time of the election
2. Nomination notice with proof of delivery (certified mail, email delivery receipts)
3. Complete ballot design with candidate names as submitted
4. Voter participation log (who voted, when, by what channel)
5. Chain-of-custody documentation for all ballots
6. Certified results with digital signature
7. Any challenges received and how they were resolved
Votem's CastIron® platform generates this file automatically at the close of every election.
## The Online Voting Advantage Post-Janus
Online voting with a compliance-first platform offers three specific advantages in the post-Janus environment:
**Participation rates.** Online voting consistently delivers 2-3x higher participation than mail ballot elections. Higher participation means a more representative result — harder to challenge on legitimacy grounds.
**Audit trails.** Every vote cast through CastIron® is logged with a timestamp, channel, and encrypted voter identifier. The audit trail is immutable and exportable in DOL-required formats.
**Speed.** When a challenge arises, Votem can produce the complete election file within hours. Paper ballot elections often require weeks to reconstruct documentation.
## Frequently Asked Questions
**Can non-member agency fee payers vote in union elections?**
After Janus, agency fee payers no longer exist in the public sector. All public-sector employees are now either members (paying dues) or non-members. LMRDA applies to private-sector unions; public-sector union elections are governed by state law and collective bargaining agreements.
**Does Janus affect LMRDA Title IV requirements?**
No. LMRDA Title IV requirements are unchanged. The Janus decision affects union finances and membership, not the federal election compliance framework.
**How long must we keep election records after a challenged election?**
LMRDA requires one year of record retention. However, if a complaint is filed with OLMS, records must be preserved until the complaint is fully resolved — which can take 18-24 months.
---
*Votem's CastIron® platform is purpose-built for LMRDA Title IV compliance. Every election includes automatic DOL-ready documentation, a complete chain-of-custody audit trail, and a $50,000 compliance guarantee.*
In June 2018, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in *Janus v. American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees* (AFSCME) that public-sector unions cannot require non-members to pay agency fees. The 5-4 decision overturned *Abood v. Detroit Board of Education* (1977), which had allowed such fees for 41 years.
The practical effect: public-sector unions saw immediate membership and revenue declines as some members chose to opt out of dues payment while retaining union representation rights.
## Why Janus Intensifies LMRDA Compliance Pressure
The Janus decision did not change LMRDA Title IV — but it changed the political and financial environment in which unions operate elections.
**Increased member scrutiny.** With members now making active choices about union participation, leadership elections face heightened scrutiny. Members who opt out of dues are still entitled to vote in officer elections under LMRDA. Any election irregularity — real or perceived — becomes a flashpoint.
**DOL complaint volume.** Following Janus, the Department of Labor's Office of Labor-Management Standards (OLMS) saw an uptick in election complaints from dissatisfied members. Unions that cannot produce a complete, auditable election file are vulnerable.
**Challenger campaigns.** Janus emboldened reform caucuses and challenger slates. Contested elections are now more common, and losing candidates are more likely to file OLMS complaints challenging the process.
## LMRDA Title IV: The Compliance Framework That Matters
LMRDA Title IV governs officer elections for private-sector unions. Key requirements include:
- **Secret ballot elections** for all local union officers
- **15-day advance notice** to all members before nominations
- **Reasonable opportunity** for all members in good standing to be candidates
- **Equal campaign rights** for all candidates
- **Preservation of all election records** for one year post-election
- **DOL oversight**: any member may file a complaint within one month of the election
## What a Defensible Election File Looks Like
A DOL-ready election file should include:
1. Voter eligibility list with dues status at the time of the election
2. Nomination notice with proof of delivery (certified mail, email delivery receipts)
3. Complete ballot design with candidate names as submitted
4. Voter participation log (who voted, when, by what channel)
5. Chain-of-custody documentation for all ballots
6. Certified results with digital signature
7. Any challenges received and how they were resolved
Votem's CastIron® platform generates this file automatically at the close of every election.
## The Online Voting Advantage Post-Janus
Online voting with a compliance-first platform offers three specific advantages in the post-Janus environment:
**Participation rates.** Online voting consistently delivers 2-3x higher participation than mail ballot elections. Higher participation means a more representative result — harder to challenge on legitimacy grounds.
**Audit trails.** Every vote cast through CastIron® is logged with a timestamp, channel, and encrypted voter identifier. The audit trail is immutable and exportable in DOL-required formats.
**Speed.** When a challenge arises, Votem can produce the complete election file within hours. Paper ballot elections often require weeks to reconstruct documentation.
## Frequently Asked Questions
**Can non-member agency fee payers vote in union elections?**
After Janus, agency fee payers no longer exist in the public sector. All public-sector employees are now either members (paying dues) or non-members. LMRDA applies to private-sector unions; public-sector union elections are governed by state law and collective bargaining agreements.
**Does Janus affect LMRDA Title IV requirements?**
No. LMRDA Title IV requirements are unchanged. The Janus decision affects union finances and membership, not the federal election compliance framework.
**How long must we keep election records after a challenged election?**
LMRDA requires one year of record retention. However, if a complaint is filed with OLMS, records must be preserved until the complaint is fully resolved — which can take 18-24 months.
---
*Votem's CastIron® platform is purpose-built for LMRDA Title IV compliance. Every election includes automatic DOL-ready documentation, a complete chain-of-custody audit trail, and a $50,000 compliance guarantee.*